Cash vs Accrual Accounting: The Choice That Shapes Your Numbers

A Houston contractor finishes a $100,000 project on December 15th. Invoice sent December 20th. Payment received January 25th.

Under cash accounting, December shows $0 revenue from this project. January shows $100,000.

Under accrual accounting, December shows $100,000 revenue. January shows $0.

Same project. Same payment. Completely different financial picture.

This isn’t just an accounting technicality. It determines when you pay taxes, how accurate your monthly reports look, and whether your financial statements reflect reality or a cash flow timing illusion.

The Core Difference

Cash basis: Record income when you receive payment. Record expenses when you pay them. Money in your hand determines when it counts.

Accrual basis: Record income when you earn it (service delivered, goods transferred). Record expenses when you incur them (you receive the goods or services). Cash timing is irrelevant to the books.

Cash basis tracks money. Accrual basis tracks economic activity.

How the Same Transaction Looks Different

Transaction	Cash Basis Records	Accrual Basis Records
Invoice client Dec 15, paid Jan 10	January (when paid)	December (when earned)
Buy supplies Dec 20, pay in 30 days	January (when paid)	December (when purchased)
Prepay 12 months insurance Dec 1	December (full amount)	Monthly over 12 months
Receive deposit for future work	When received (as income)	When work is performed

The same December in the same business looks profitable under one method and break-even under another.

Why Cash Basis Is Simpler

Look at your bank account. Money in equals revenue. Money out equals expenses. End of story.

There’s no tracking receivables. No managing payables. No accruing expenses you haven’t paid yet. A Houston freelancer with simple transactions can manage cash basis bookkeeping in a fraction of the time accrual would require.

Cash Basis Advantages

Direct cash visibility. If you’re profitable on the books, you have the cash to show for it. No wondering where the money went.

Tax timing flexibility. Delay collecting a December invoice until January, and the income shifts to the next tax year. This isn’t cheating. It’s strategic timing within the rules.

Lower bookkeeping costs. Simpler systems mean less work. Less work means lower fees if you outsource.

Easier to understand. For business owners who aren’t accountants, cash basis feels intuitive. The numbers match what you see in the bank.

Cash Basis Limitations

Incomplete picture. Cash accounting doesn’t show money clients owe you (accounts receivable) or bills you haven’t paid yet (accounts payable). You could look profitable while sitting on a pile of unpaid bills coming due next week.

Volatile monthly results. A month where you collect several large payments looks fantastic. A month where you do the work but haven’t invoiced yet looks terrible. The volatility makes trend analysis difficult.

Lender and investor concerns. Banks often require accrual-basis financial statements. They want to see the full picture, including what’s owed to you and what you owe.

Revenue matching problems. If you incur costs in December but receive payment in February, matching revenue to related expenses becomes messy.

Why Accrual Basis Is More Accurate

Accrual accounting captures economic reality, not just cash movement.

Complete the work in December, and December’s books show the revenue. Incur costs in December, and December’s books show those costs. The matching principle ensures each period tells a coherent story about actual business activity.

Accrual Basis Advantages

True financial position. Revenue when earned. Expenses when incurred. Receivables and payables on the balance sheet. This is what your business actually looks like financially.

Better matching. Complete a project in December, and both the revenue and project costs appear in December. You can actually see whether that project was profitable.

Reliable trends. Monthly statements reflect actual business activity, not cash timing accidents. Spot real patterns rather than payment cycle noise.

Lender and investor ready. Professional financial reporting uses accrual accounting. If you’re seeking loans or investment, accrual basis is what they expect.

Accrual Basis Limitations

More complex bookkeeping. You must track accounts receivable, accounts payable, deferred revenue, prepaid expenses. Each requires attention and accuracy.

Cash flow disconnect. Profitable on paper doesn’t mean cash in the bank. A Houston contractor showing $50,000 profit might have $40,000 tied up in receivables from slow-paying clients. Many profitable businesses fail because accrual profits masked cash flow crises.

Less tax timing control. Income is taxed when earned, not when received. You might owe taxes on revenue you haven’t collected yet.

Higher costs. More complex systems need more expertise. Expect higher bookkeeping and accounting fees.

What the IRS Requires

Most small businesses can choose either method. The IRS allows cash basis for:

• Sole proprietors
• Partnerships without a C-corporation partner
• S-corporations
• C-corporations with average annual gross receipts under $30 million (over the prior 3 years)
• Most service businesses

The IRS requires accrual basis for:

• C-corporations exceeding the $30 million gross receipts threshold
• Tax shelters
• Certain farming operations

The Inventory Exception

Previously, businesses with inventory had to use accrual accounting. Current rules allow small businesses (under $30 million gross receipts) to use cash basis even with inventory, treating it as non-incidental materials and supplies.

This means a Houston retailer under the threshold can still choose cash basis.

Switching Methods Later

Want to change from cash to accrual (or vice versa)? It’s possible, but it’s not casual.

You must:

1. File Form 3115 (Application for Change in Accounting Method)
2. Calculate the “Section 481(a) adjustment” (the cumulative difference between methods)
3. Spread this adjustment over future tax years (usually 4 years for increases)

The paperwork is significant. The calculations are technical. This is CPA territory, not DIY.

Making the Right Choice

Choose Cash Basis If:

• Your business is straightforward (few receivables and payables)
• You’re a solo service provider or freelancer
• Cash flow management is your priority
• You want simpler, cheaper bookkeeping
• You don’t need financial statements for lenders or investors

Choose Accrual Basis If:

• You have significant accounts receivable and payable
• You need accurate monthly financial statements
• You’re seeking bank loans or investors
• You want to match revenue with related expenses clearly
• The IRS requires it for your business type

The Hybrid Approach

Some businesses use both:

• Cash basis for tax returns (simpler, tax timing control)
• Accrual basis for internal reporting (better financial insights)

This requires maintaining two sets of books. It adds complexity but provides benefits of both methods for businesses that need sophisticated internal reporting while preferring cash basis for taxes.

A Houston Construction Example

Scenario: A Houston contractor completes a $100,000 project.

• December 15: Project completed
• December 20: Invoice sent
• January 25: Payment received
• December labor and material costs: $70,000

Cash Basis:

• December: $0 revenue, $70,000 expenses = $70,000 loss
• January: $100,000 revenue, $0 expenses = $100,000 profit

December looks like a disaster. January looks like a windfall. Neither month tells the truth about the project.

Accrual Basis:

• December: $100,000 revenue, $70,000 expenses = $30,000 profit
• January: No impact from this project

December accurately shows a $30,000 profitable project. The financial statements match reality.

Questions to Help You Decide

1. What does the IRS require for your business type and size?
2. How complex are your receivables and payables?
3. Do you need financial statements for external parties?
4. What’s your tolerance for bookkeeping complexity?
5. How important is tax timing flexibility?

For most Houston small businesses, especially service providers, freelancers, and contractors under the $30 million threshold, cash basis offers simplicity and tax flexibility. But as you grow, add complexity, or seek financing, accrual accounting becomes increasingly valuable.

Getting Expert Guidance

The accounting method you choose affects your taxes, your financial reporting, and your bookkeeping workload for years. Switching later is possible but complicated.

At EZQ Group, we help Houston businesses select the right accounting method, set up proper bookkeeping systems, and maintain clean records regardless of method. Whether you’re starting fresh or reconsidering your current approach, we can help you make an informed decision.

Questions about which method is right for you? Contact us to discuss your situation.

---

This article provides general information and is not tax advice. Tax situations vary, and you should consult with a qualified tax professional about your specific circumstances.